Saturday, November 26, 2011

Chapter Five: Spiritual Death and Spiritual Life: Rebirth and Faith

(all written by RC Sproul)


Reformed theology is famous for a simple acrostic that was designed to summarize the so-called “Five Points of Calvinism.”  It spells the word TULIP.

                T – Total Depravity
                U – Unconditional Election
                L – Limited Atonement
                I – Irresistible Grace
    P – Perseverance of the Saints

                This acrostic has helped many people remember the distinctives of Reformed theology.  Unfortunately, it has also caused great confusion and much misunderstanding.  The problem with acrostics is that the best terms we have for ideas don’t always start with letters that will spell neat little words.  The acrostic serves well as a memory device, but that is about all.
                My first problem with the acrostic TULIP is with the first letter.  Total depravity is a very misleading term.  The concept of total depravity is often confused with the idea of utter depravity.  In Reformed theology total depravity refers to the idea that our whole humanity is fallen.  That is, there is no part of me that has not been affected in some way by the Fall.  Sin affects my will, my heart, my mind, and my body.  If Adam had never sinned, I suppose he would not have had the need to wear bifocals when he reached middle age.  In fact the very term middle age would have been meaningless to him.  Had he not sinned, Adam would not have died.  When one lives forever, where is middle age?
                Total depravity also stresses the fact that sin reaches to the core of our being.  Sin is not a peripheral thing, a slight blemish that mars an otherwise perfect specimen.  Sin is radical in the sense that it touches the root (radix) of our lives.
                Total depravity is not utter depravity.  Utter depravity would mean that we are all as sinful as we possibly could be.  We know that is not the case.  No matter how much each of us has sinned, we are able to think of worse sins that we could have committed.  Even Adolf Hitler refrained from murdering his mother.
                Since total depravity is often confused with utter depravity, I prefer to speak of the “radical corruption” of man.  That does mess up our acrostic.  What in the world is a rulip?  The concept of the radical character of sin is perhaps the most important concept for us to understand if we are going to make any sense out of the biblical doctrine of predestination.  As I mentioned during our discussion of man’s moral inability, this is the focal point of the entire debate.
                I remember teaching a college class in theology.  The class was made up of an interdenominational group of about twenty-five students.  I asked at the beginning of the study on predestination how many students considered themselves Calvinists on the matter.  Only one student raised his hand.
                We started with a study of man’s sinfulness.  After I lectured for several days on the subject of man’s corruption I took another poll.  I asked, “How many of you are persuaded that what you have just learned is in fact the Bible doctrine of human sinfulness?”  Every hand went up.  I said, “Are you sure?”  They insisted that they were indeed sure.  I gave a further warning.  “Be careful now.  This may come back to haunt you later in the course.”  No matter.  They insisted they were convinced.
                At this point in the class I went to the corner of the chalkboard and wrote the date.  Next to the date I wrote the figure 25.  I put a circle around this and added a note to the janitor to please refrain from erasing this portion of the board.
                Several weeks later we began a study of predestination.  When I got to the point of man’s moral inability there were howls of protest.  Then I went to the chalkboard and reminded them of the earlier poll.  It took another two weeks to convince them that, if they really accepted the biblical view of human corruption, the debate about predestination for all intents and purposes was already over.
                I shall, in brief, attempt to do the same thing here. I proceed with the same caution.

The Biblical View of Human Corruption
                Let us begin our study of the degree of man’s fallenness by looking at Romans 3.  Here the Apostle Paul writes:

There is none righteous, no, not one; there is none who understands; there is none who seeks after God.  They have all gone out of the way; they have together become unprofitable; there is none who does good, no, not one (Romans 3:10-12).

                Here we find a brief summation of the universality of human corruption.  Sin is so pervasive that it captures everyone in its net.  Paul uses words of emphasis to show that there are no exceptions to this indictment among fallen men.  There is none righteous; there is none who does good.
                The statement “There is none who does good, no, not one” flies in the face of our cultural assumptions.  We grow up hearing that nobody is perfect and that to err is human.  We are quite willing to acknowledge that none of us is perfect.  That we are sinners is easy to admit; that none of us even does good is a bit much.  Not one person in a thousand will admit that sin is this serious.
                No one does good?  How can that be?  Every day we see rank pagans doing some good.  We see them performing heroic acts of sacrifice, works of industry, prudence, and honesty.  We see unbelievers scrupulously obeying the speed limits while cars whiz by them bearing bumper stickers that read, “Honk if you love Jesus.”
                Paul must be using hyperbole here.  He must be intentionally exaggerating in order to make a point.  Surely there are people who do good.  No!  The sober judgment of God is that no one does good, no, not one.
                We stumble here because we have a relative understanding of what good is.  Good is, indeed, a relative term.  Something can only be judged good according to some sort of standard.  We use the term as a comparison among men.  When we say that a man is good, we mean that he is good compared with other men.  But the ultimate standard for goodness, the standard by which we shall be judged, is the law of God.  That law is not God, but it comes from God and reflects the perfect character of God himself.  Judged against that standard, no one is good.
                In biblical categories a good deed is measured in two parts.  The first is in its outward conformity to the law of God.  This means that, if God prohibits stealing, then it is good not to steal.  It is good to tell the truth.  It is good to pay our bills on time.  It is good to assist people in need.  Outwardly these virtues are performed every day.  When we see them we quickly conclude that men do in fact do good things.
                It is the second part of the measuring that gets us in trouble.  Before God pronounces a deed “good” he considers not only the outward or external conformity to his law, but also the motivation.  We look only at outward appearances; God reads the heart.  For a work to be considered good it must not only conform outwardly to the law of God, but it must be motivated inwardly by a sincere love for God.
                We remember the Great Commandment to love the Lord our God with all our hearts, all our strength, and all our minds…and love our neighbors as much as we love ourselves.  Every deed that we do should proceed from a heart that loves God totally.
                From this perspective it is easy to see that no one does good.  Our best works are tainted by our less than pure motives.  No one among us has ever loved God with all of his heart or with all of his mind.  There is a pound of flesh mixed in with all of our deeds, rendering them less than perfect.
                Jonathan Edwards spoke of the concept of enlightened self-interest.  Enlightened self-interest refers to that motivation we all feel to perform external righteousness and to restrain some evil impulses within ourselves.  There are certain times and places where crime does not pay.  Where the risk of punishment outweighs the possible reward of our misdeed, we may be inclined to refrain from it.  On the other hand, we may win the applause of men by our virtuous acts.  We may gain a pat on the head from our teacher or the respect of our peers if we do certain good deeds.
                The whole world applauds recording artists when they band together to produce a special album with the proceeds to be used to relieve famine in Ethiopia.  Applause rarely hurts the career of a stage performer, despite cynical statements that ethics and business do not mix.  On the contrary, most of us have learned that ethics enhance our reputations in business.
                I am not so cynical as to think that the gesture for Ethiopia by singers was done purely for personal applause or as a publicity stunt.  Surely there were strong motives of compassion and care for starving people.  On the other hand, I am not so naïve as to think that the motives were totally without self-interest, but no matter how minuscule, there was at least a grain of self-interest mixed in.  There always is, in all of us.  If we deny this I suspect that our very denials are motivated in part by self-interest.
                We want to deny this allegation.  We sense in our own hearts at times an overwhelming feeling of performing from duty alone.  We like to think that we are truly altruistic.  But no one ever flatters us more than we flatter ourselves.  The weight of our motives may at times lean heavily in the direction of altruism, but it is never perfectly there.
                God does not grade on a curve.  He demands perfection.  None of us performs on that level.  We do not do what God commands.  Ever.  Therefore the apostle is not indulging himself with hyperbole.  His judgment is accurate.  There is none who does good, no, not one.  Jesus himself reinforced this view in his discussion with the rich young ruler.  “No one is good but One, that is, God” (Luke 18:19).
                As troublesome as this indictment is, another element in the Romans passage may bring even more consternation to us, especially to evangelical Christians who talk and think to the contrary.  Paul says, “There is none who seeks after God.”
                How many times have you heard Christians say, or have you heard the words from your own mouth, “So and so is not a Christian, but he’s searching”?  It is a common statement among Christians.  The idea is that there are people all over the place who are searching for God.  Their problem is that they just haven’t been able to find him.  He is playing hide and seek.  He is elusive.
                In the Garden of Eden when sin came into the world, who hid?  Jesus came into the world to seek and to save the lost.  Jesus wasn’t the one who was hiding.  God is not a fugitive.  We are the ones on the run.  Scripture declares that the wicked flee when no man pursues.  As Luther remarked, “The pagan trembles at the rustling of a leaf.”  The uniform teaching of Scripture is that fallen men are fleeing from God.  There is none who seeks after God.
                Why is it then, despite such clear biblical teaching to the contrary, that Christians persist in claiming that they know people who are searching for God but have not yet found him?  St. Thomas Aquinas shed some light on this.  Aquinas said that we confuse two similar yet different human actions.  We see people searching desperately for peace of mind, relief from guilt, meaning and purpose to their lives, and loving acceptance.  We know that ultimately these things can only be found in God.  Therefore we conclude that since people are seeking these things they must be seeking after God.
                People do not seek God.  They seek after the benefits that only God can give them.  The sin of fallen man is this: Man seeks the benefits of God while at the same time fleeing from God himself.  We are, by nature, fugitives.
                The Bible tells us repeatedly to seek after God.  The Old Testament cries, “Seek the Lord while He may be found” (Isa. 55:6).  Jesus said, “Seek, and you will find; knock, and it will be opened to you” (Matt. 7:7).  The conclusion we draw from these texts is that since we are called to seek after God is must mean that we, even in our fallen state, have the moral capacity to do that seeking.  But who is being addressed in these texts?  In the case of the Old Testament it is the people of Israel who are called to seek the Lord.  In the New Testament it is believers who are called to seek the kingdom.
                We have all heard evangelists quote from Revelation: “I stand at the door and knock.  If anyone hears My voice and opens the door, I will come in to him and dine with him, and he with Me” (Rev. 3:20).  Usually the evangelist applies this text as an appeal to the unconverted, saying, “Jesus is knocking at the door of your heart.  If you open the door he will come in.”  In the original saying, however, Jesus directed his remarks to the church.  It was not an evangelistic appeal.
                So what?  The point is that seeking is something that unbelievers to not do on their own steam.  The unbeliever will not seek.  The unbeliever will not knock.  Seeking is the business of believers.  Edwards said, “The seeking of the kingdom of God is the chief business of the Christian life.”  Seeking is the result of faith, not the cause of it.
                When we are converted to Christ, we use language of discovery to express our conversion.  We speak of finding Christ.  We may have a bumper sticker that reads I FOUND IT.  These statements are indeed true.  The irony is this:  Once we have found Christ it is not the end of our seeking, but the beginning.  Usually, when we find what we are looking for, it signals the end of our searching.  But when we “find” Christ, it is the beginning of our search.  The Christian life begins at conversion; it does not end where it begins.  It grows; it moves from faith to faith, from grace to grace, from life to life.  This movement of growth is prodded by a continual seeking after God.
                There is one more insight in Romans 3 that we need to look at briefly.  Not only does the apostle declare that no one seeks after God, but he adds the thought, “They have together become unprofitable.”  We must remember that here Paul is speaking of fallen men, natural men, unconverted men.  This is a description of people who are still in the flesh.
                What does Paul mean by unprofitable?  Jesus earlier spoke of unprofitable servants.  Profit has to do with positive values.  The unconverted person, working in the flesh, achieves nothing of permanent value.  In the flesh he may gain the whole world but he loses the thing of most value to himself, his own soul.  The most valuable possession a person can ever have is Christ.  He is the pearl of great price.  To have him is to have the greatest possible profit.
                The person who is spiritually dead cannot, in his own flesh, gain the profit of Christ.  He is described as one who has no fear of God before his eyes (Romans 3:18).  Those who are not righteous, who do no good, who never seek after God, who are altogether unprofitable, and who have no fear of God before their eyes, never incline their own hearts to Christ.

No comments:

Post a Comment