(all written by RC Sproul)
God’s Sovereignty and Human Freedom
Every Christian gladly affirms that God is sovereign. God’s sovereignty is a comfort to us. It assures us that he is able to do what he promises to do. But the bare fact of God’s sovereignty raises one more big question. How is God’s sovereignty related to human freedom?
When we stand before the question of divine sovereignty and human freedom, the “fight or flight” dilemma may confront us. We might try to fight our way into a logical solution of it or take a turn and run as fast as we can from it.
Many of us choose to flee from it. The flight takes different routes. The most common is simply to say that divine sovereignty and human freedom are contradictions that we must have the courage to embrace. We seek analogies that soothe our troubled minds.
As a college student I heard two analogies that gave me temporary relief, like a theological package of Rolaids:
Analogy #1 – “God’s sovereignty and human freedom and like parallel lines that meet in eternity.”
Analogy #2 – “God’s sovereignty and human freedom are like ropes in a well. On the surface they seem to be separate, but in the darkness of the bottom of the well they come together.”
The first time I heard these analogies I was relieved. They sounded simple yet profound. The idea of two parallel lines that meet in eternity satisfied me. It gave me something clever to say in the event that a hard-boiled skeptic asked me about divine sovereignty and human freedom.
My relief was temporary. I soon required a stronger dose of Rolaids. The nagging question refused to go away. How, I wondered, can parallel lines ever meet? In eternity or anywhere else? If the lines meet, then they are not ultimately parallel. If they are ultimately parallel, then they will never meet. The more I thought about the analogy the more I realized that it did not solve the problem. To say that parallel lines meet in eternity is a nonsense statement; it is a blatant contradiction.
I don’t like contradictions. I find little comfort in them. I never cease to be amazed at the ease with which Christians seem to be comfortable with them. I hear statements like, “God is bigger than logic!” or “Faith is higher than reason!” to defend the use of contradictions in theology.
I certainly agree that God is bigger than logic and that faith is higher than reason. I agree with all my heart and with all my head. What I want to avoid is a God who is smaller than logic and a faith that is lower than reason. A God who is smaller than logic would be and should be destroyed by logic. A faith that is lower than reason is irrational and absurd.
I suppose it is the tension between divine sovereignty and human freedom, more than any other issue, that has driven many Christians to claim contradictions as a legitimate element of faith. The idea is that logic cannot reconcile divine sovereignty and human freedom. The two defy logical harmony. Since the Bible teaches both poles of the contradiction we must be willing to affirm them both, in spite of the fact that they are contradictory.
God forbid! For Christians to embrace both poles of a blatant contradiction is to commit intellectual suicide and to slander the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit is not the author of confusion. God does not speak with a forked tongue.
If human freedom and divine sovereignty are real contradictions, then one of them, at least, has to go. If sovereignty excludes freedom and freedom excludes sovereignty, then either God is not sovereign or man is not free.
Happily, there is an alternative. We can keep both sovereignty and freedom if we can show that they are not contradictory.
At a human level we readily see that people can enjoy a real measure of freedom in a land ruled by a sovereign monarch. It is not freedom that is canceled out by sovereignty; it is autonomy that cannot coexist with sovereignty.
What is autonomy? The word comes from the prefix auto and the root nomos. Auto means “self.” An automobile is something that moves itself. “Automatic” describes something that is self-acting.
The root nomos is the Greek word for “law.” The word autonomy means, then, “self-law.” To be autonomous means to be a law unto oneself. An autonomous creature would be answerable to no one. He would have no governor, least of all a sovereign governor. It is logically impossible to have a sovereign God existing at the same time as an autonomous creature. The two concepts are utterly incompatible. To think of their coexistence would be like imagining the meeting of an immovable object and an irresistible force. What would happen? If the object moved, then it could no longer be considered immovable. If it failed to move, then the irresistible force would no longer be irresistible.
So it is with sovereignty and autonomy. If God is sovereign, man cannot possibly be autonomous. If man is autonomous, God cannot possibly be sovereign. These would be contradictions.
One does not have to be autonomous to be free. Autonomy implies absolute freedom. We are free, but there are limits to our freedom. The ultimate limit is the sovereignty of God.
I once read a statement by a Christian who said, “God’s sovereignty can never restrict human freedom.” Imagine a Christian thinker making such a statement. This is sheer humanism. Does the law of God place restrictions on human freedom? Is God not permitted to impose limits on what I may choose? Not only may God impose moral limits upon my freedom, but he has every right at any moment to strike me dead if it is necessary to restrain me from exercising my evil choices. If God has no right of coercion, then he has no right of governing his creation.
It is better that we reverse the statement: “Human freedom can never restrict the sovereignty of God.” That is what sovereignty is all about. If God’s sovereignty is restricted by man’s freedom, then God is not sovereign; man is sovereign.
God is free. I am free. God is more free than I am. If my freedom runs up against God’s freedom, I lose. His freedom restricts mine; my freedom does not restrict his. There is an analogy in the human family. I have a free will. My children have free wills. When our wills clash I have the authority to overrule their wills. Their wills are to be subordinate to my will; my will is not subordinate to theirs. Of course at the human level of the analogy we are not speaking in absolute terms.
Divine sovereignty and human freedom are often thought to be contradictions because on the surface they sound contradictory. There are some important distinctions that must be made and consistently applied to this question if we are to avoid hopeless confusion.
Let us consider three words in our vocabulary that are so closely related that they are often confused:
1. Contradiction
2. Paradox
3. Mystery
1. Contradiction. The logical law of contradiction says that a thing cannot be what it is and not be what it is at the same time and in the same relationship. A man can be a father and a son at the same time, but he cannot be a man and not be a man at the same time. A man can be both a father and a son at the same time but not in the same relationship. No man can be his own father. Even when we speak of Jesus as the God/man we are careful to say that, though he is God and man at the same time, he is not God and man in the same relationship. He has a divine nature and a human nature. They are not to be confused. Contradictions can never coexist, not even in the mind of God. If both poles of a genuine contradiction could be true in the mind of God, then nothing God ever revealed to us could possibly have any meaning. If good and evil, justice and injustice, righteousness and unrighteousness, Christ and Antichrist could all mean the same thing to God’s mind, then truth of any kind would be utterly impossible.
2. Paradox. A paradox is an apparent contradiction that upon closer scrutiny can be resolved. I have heard teachers declare that the Christian notion of the Trinity is a contradiction. It simply is not. It violates no law of logic. It passes the objective test of the law of contradiction. God is one in essence and three in person. There is nothing contradictory about that. If we said that God was one in essence and three is essence then we would have a bona fide contradiction that no one could resolve. Then Christianity would be hopelessly irrational and absurd. The Trinity is a paradox, but not a contradiction.
Fogging things up even further is another term, antinomy. Its primary meaning is a synonym for contradiction but its secondary meaning is a synonym for paradox. Upon examination, we see that it has the same root as autonomy, nomos, which means “law.” Here the prefix is anti, which means “against” or “instead of.” Thus the literal meaning of the term antinomy is “against law.” What law do you suppose is in view here? The law of contradiction. The original meaning of the term was “that which violates the law of contradiction.” Hence, originally and in normal philosophical discussion, the word antinomy is an exact equivalent of the word contradiction.
Confusion creeps in when people us the term antinomy not to refer to a genuine contradiction but to a paradox or apparent contradiction. We remember that a paradox is a statement that seems like a contradiction but actually isn’t. In Great Britain, especially, the word antinomy is often used as a synonym for paradox.
I labor these fine distinctions for two reasons. The first is that if we are to avoid confusion we must have a clear idea in our minds of the crucial difference between a real contradiction and a seeming contradiction. It is the difference between rationality and irrationality, between truth and absurdity.
The second reason that it is necessary to state these definitions clearly is that one of the greatest defenders of the doctrine of predestination in our world today uses the tern antimony. I am thinking of the outstanding theologian, Dr. J. I. Packer. Packer has helped countless thousands of people come to a deeper understanding of the character of God, especially with regard to God’s sovereignty.
I have never discussed this matter with Dr. Packer’s use of the term antinomy with him. I assume he is using it in the British sense of paradox. I cannot imagine that he means to speak of actual contradictions in the Word of God. In fact, in his book Evangelism and the Sovereignty of God, he labors the point that there are no ultimate contradictions in the truth of God. Dr. Packer has not only been tireless in his defense of Christian theology, but has been equally tireless in his brilliant defense of the inerrancy of the Bible. If the Bible contained antinomies in the sense of real contradictions, that would be the end of inerrancy.
Some people actually do hold that there are real contradictions in divine truth. They think inerrancy is compatible with them. Inerrancy would then mean that the Bible inerrantly reveals the contradictions in God’s truth. Of course a moment’s thought would make clear that if God’s truth is contradictory truth it is no truth at all. Indeed the very word truth would be emptied of meaning. If contradictions can be true we would have no possible way of discerning the difference between truth and a lie. This is why I am convinced that Dr. Packer uses antinomy to mean paradox and not contradiction.
3. Mystery. The term mystery refers to that which is true but which we do not understand. The Trinity, for example, is a mystery. I cannot penetrate the mystery of the Trinity or of the incarnation of Christ with my feeble mind. Such truths are too high for me. I know that Jesus was one person with two natures but I don’t understand how that can be. The same kind of thing is found in the natural realm. Who understands the nature of gravity, or even of motion? Who has penetrated the ultimate mystery of life? What philosopher has plumbed the depths of the meaning of the human self? These are mysteries. They are not contradictions.
It is easy to confuse mystery and contradiction. We do not understand either of them. No one understands contradiction because contradictions are intrinsically unintelligible. Not even God can understand a contradiction. Contradictions are nonsense. No one can make sense out of them.
Mysteries are capable of being understood. The New Testament reveals to us things that were concealed and not understood in the Old Testament times. There are things that once were mysterious to us that are now understood. This does not mean that everything that is presently a mystery to us will one day be made clear, but that many current mysteries will be unraveled for us. Some will be penetrated in this world. We have not yet reached the limits of human discovery. We know also that in heaven things will be revealed to us that are still hidden. But even in heaven we will not grasp fully the meaning of infinity. To understand that fully, one must himself be infinite. God can understand infinity, not because he operates on the basis of some kind of heavenly logic system, but because he himself is infinite. He has an infinite perspective.
Let me state it another way: All contradictions are mysterious. Not all mysteries are contradictions. Christianity has plenty of room for mysteries. It has no room for contradictions. Mysteries may be true. Contradictions can never be true, neither here in our minds, nor there in God’s mind.
The big issue remains. The grand debate that stirs the cauldron of controversy centers on the question, “What does predestination do to our free will?”
We will examine that issue in the next chapter.
No comments:
Post a Comment